Don’t Encourage Paper Tigers
We’ve all experienced it: a drawn-out uber-long email, text, or Slack message used to sidestep human interaction. It’s easy to send—and even easier to fall into the trap of reading it and reacting. But it’s toxic. This article breaks down the rise of the “paper tiger” in the AI world and gives business owners clear, practical steps to spot it and prevent it from taking root in their lives.
In today's AI-driven, hyper-digital business landscape, it's easier than ever to sound confident, authoritative, even aggressive without ever speaking a word aloud. We've all received those messages: paragraphs upon paragraphs, full of strong language, forceful directives, and calculated punctuation. But peel back the layers and you'll often find the sender is someone who, in person, struggles to speak plainly, avoid confrontation, or engage with real presence.
This is the paper tiger of the modern workplace: someone who appears fierce in writing but lacks real-world conviction. The danger? It's becoming more common, and business owners need to stop normalizing it.
The Artificial Confidence of Digital Communication
Digital tools have improved productivity, but they’ve also created room for artificial behavior. In the absence of tone, body language, and real-time feedback, email, Slack, text messages, and other platforms give people space to inflate their confidence. Add AI-generated language, and it’s even easier to sound like someone you’re not.
“This mismatch between digital presence and human interaction isn't harmless. It creates confusion, erodes trust, and weakens company culture.”
The Cost of Avoiding Real Conversations
Overly long, emotionally loaded messages often mask discomfort with confrontation. But successful businesses are built on clear, direct exchanges—not avoidance.
One of the most serious issues in any business relationship is when people can’t have tough conversations professionally. Whether it’s addressing performance, pricing, expectations, or disagreements, avoiding these conversations leads to deeper problems. It causes misalignment, delays decisions, and ultimately damages working relationships.
Worse, it creates a pattern where avoidance is tolerated. This trains others to do the same, and eventually, you’re surrounded by people who only speak clearly from behind a screen—if at all.
The risks are real: unresolved tension, poor performance, accountability gaps, and constant second-guessing. It breeds anxiety in your team and frustration in your partnerships. The longer it’s allowed, the harder it is to undo.
That’s why business owners must act quickly, even if it means risking a client relationship or upsetting an employee. You are not obligated to tolerate dysfunction. Cutting ties with someone who refuses to engage directly might feel like a short-term loss, but it protects your long-term health. You free up time, avoid miscommunication, and preserve your business integrity.
Text and email were never designed for real, meaningful conversation. Think about delivering critical project feedback, resolving a misunderstanding with a long-time client, or navigating tension with a business partner—these situations demand the nuance of real-time interaction. While not every communication is mission-critical, many require more than a keyboard can deliver. Some things require more. And in business, direct human exchange is non-negotiable.
Business owners who accept passive-aggressive emails or Slack rants in place of real discussions are training everyone around them to hide, not engage.
Business owners who accept passive-aggressive emails or Slack rants in place of real discussions are training their teams to hide, not lead.
AI Is a Tool, Not a Personality
AI tools can make writing easier, but they don’t replace the need for direct and clear communication. When used to sound more confident than someone actually is, they create a false impression. That can waste time, slow decisions, and lead to misunderstandings.
Stick with tools that clarify, not distort. Use AI to clean up wording, not cover up insecurity. Everyone you work with should be able to explain themselves clearly and directly when needed.
How to Spot and Address the Paper Tiger in Your Business
Watch for mismatches
If someone is bold in messages but hesitant or disengaged in person, take note. This contrast suggests they may be using digital communication to mask discomfort or insecurity.Require live conversations
Make it policy that big or sensitive topics must be discussed face-to-face or at least over the phone. Written messages lack tone and often escalate problems that a live conversation can resolve quickly.Set the standard
If you default to email when a quick call would solve the issue, others will too. Set a clear expectation: important topics get real-time discussion. Prioritize simple, direct, timely conversations.Don’t reward avoidance
If someone always communicates behind a screen, address it directly. Ask for live check-ins and real discussion. Don’t accept digital-only participation in place of real involvement.Shut down escalation
If you see long or heated Slack threads or emails spiraling, intervene. Say, “Let’s talk live,” and move it to a call. Don't let digital back-and-forth replace resolution.
Human Interaction Is a Strategic Asset
Business owners—avoid being a paper tiger, and don’t tolerate it in your clients, partners, employees, or peers. A person who only speaks boldly behind a screen is not showing strength. They’re hiding. Discourage overly long, emotionally charged emails or Slack messages when a direct conversation would be more effective. Train everyone you work with to engage in human interactions that are succinct, professional, and relevant.
Text and email will never replace presence. While not every situation requires a meeting, many do. If someone won’t hop on a call to resolve conflict or clarify direction, ask yourself if they’re a reliable fit.
Choosing not to work with paper tigers pays off. You’ll have fewer misunderstandings, faster decision-making, more trust, and less drama. Your culture will run cleaner. Your business will move quicker. And your sanity will thank you.
The digital world is artificial. But your business isn’t. Culture, trust, clarity, and accountability depend on authentic, real-time interaction.
Because business doesn’t run on digital performance. It runs on people who are clear, direct, and willing to engage in real time. And paper tigers don’t hold up under pressure.
Invest in real voices. Protect real relationships. Prioritize human connection.
Are you a business owner?
We empower business owners. Start, run, and grow your business while prioritizing what matters most.
